ArthurCrane – generally positive ("Rumble is a very good example of how you can make a non-villain character unlikeable, but nonetheless interesting.")
Batbrony Reviews – very positive ("a fun CMC episode with a very good, well-written lesson at its heart)
Cuddlepug – extremely negative (graded D-; "a spiteful episode ... almost entirely without merit")
Derpy News – broadly positive (graded B+; "not overly spectacular, but ... a good episode nonetheless")
Louder Yay – mildly positive (three stars ("just"); "a pretty average episode of FiM – but that's still better than many shows' average.")
MLEEP Reviews – extremely positive (9.5/10; "a marvelous episode that was full of surprises")
Pony Press News Journal – mixed (6/10; "I found most of this episode boring until the point where the Cutie Mark Crusaders and Rumble have an argument")
The Super Mario Brony Blog – positive (4/5; ""yet another good moral ... a well constructed plot ... and more great moments from the Crusaders ... strong, if imperfect")
TheDragonWarlock – rather negative (graded C; "It wants to be ambitious, but it's held back by how its botched execution.")
Thrond Media Pony Corner – negative (43%; " yet another crushingly dull entry in what's shaping up to be a crushingly dull season")
Well I've just now got it done, AND my review for Once Upon a Zeppelin's now up.
ReplyDeleteMarks and Recreation - 4/5 (Great way for May Chan to redeem herself after Not Asking for Trouble *that episode SUCKED*)
Once Upon a Zeppelin - 3.5/5 (Good, but not great)
I'll add this one in now. And I'll include you in the "OUaZ" roundup, too.
DeleteWow. Quite a spread of opinions on that episode.
ReplyDeleteYes, that was very noticeable. Admittedly Cuddlepug tends to be negative and MLEEP tends to be positive, but even allowing for that I think the spread was wider than usual.
Delete