Friday, 13 October 2017

Text Review Roundup: "Marks and Recreation"

I've let this feature slip a bit recently! I'll do a TRR for "Once Upon a Zeppelin" in the next few days, though that for tomorrow's episode may well have to wait until after I get back from UK PonyCon. On the plus side, being late means I have an ArthurCrane review to include! Also, a new reviewer: Pony Press News Journal. Still no reviews from The Southern Nerd or the Super Mario Brony Blog, so those sources have been removed from the list.

ArthurCrane – generally positive ("Rumble is a very good example of how you can make a non-villain character unlikeable, but nonetheless interesting.")

Batbrony Reviews – very positive ("a fun CMC episode with a very good, well-written lesson at its heart)

Cuddlepug – extremely negative (graded D-; "a spiteful episode ... almost entirely without merit")

Derpy News – broadly positive (graded B+; "not overly spectacular, but ... a good episode nonetheless")

Louder Yay – mildly positive (three stars ("just"); "a pretty average episode of FiM – but that's still better than many shows' average.")

MLEEP Reviews – extremely positive (9.5/10; "a marvelous episode that was full of surprises")

Pony Press News Journal – mixed (6/10; "I found most of this episode boring until the point where the Cutie Mark Crusaders and Rumble have an argument")

The Super Mario Brony Blog – positive (4/5; ""yet another good moral ... a well constructed plot ... and more great moments from the Crusaders ... strong, if imperfect")

TheDragonWarlock – rather negative (graded C; "It wants to be ambitious, but it's held back by how its botched execution.")

Thrond Media Pony Corner – negative (43%; " yet another crushingly dull entry in what's shaping up to be a crushingly dull season")

4 comments:

  1. Well I've just now got it done, AND my review for Once Upon a Zeppelin's now up.

    Marks and Recreation - 4/5 (Great way for May Chan to redeem herself after Not Asking for Trouble *that episode SUCKED*)

    Once Upon a Zeppelin - 3.5/5 (Good, but not great)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll add this one in now. And I'll include you in the "OUaZ" roundup, too.

      Delete
  2. Wow. Quite a spread of opinions on that episode.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, that was very noticeable. Admittedly Cuddlepug tends to be negative and MLEEP tends to be positive, but even allowing for that I think the spread was wider than usual.

      Delete