Wednesday 31 August 2022

Ponyfic Roundup 407

Read it Later story count: 92 (+2) 

The final Ponyfic Roundup of meteorological summer is upon us. Unless you're somewhere that has different seasons, or is in the Southern Hemisphere, in which case fill in your own appropriate phrase. Four more fics to consider today, and they're as follows:

Who We Are by kits
A Clean Break by Circumlocution
The Ones We Can't See
by applejackofalltrades
Flat-Earth Fluttershy by Jinzhou

★: 0 | ★★: 1 | ★★★: 3 | ★★★★: 0 | ★★★★★: 0
Note: I use a skewed rating system. A fic I enjoy an average amount scores two stars.

Monday 29 August 2022

My Little Repeats 121: "On Your Marks"

"I thought you said our show had easy songs!"
S6E04: "On Your Marks"

9 Apr 2016

My original rating: ★★★
IMDb score: 7.0

The one with bubblegum pony

Thoughts: Time for a CMC episode. In fact, one where the Mane Six aren't a factor at all – as in, bar the opening credits they don't have a single second of screen time. Dave Polsky was by this point the only remaining writer who'd penned episodes in season 1. Here, he gives us a pretty solid outing. Okay, the pacing isn't quite spot on, with Tender Taps taking a bit too long to get where he does. The Bulk Biceps segment isn't quite as funny as it thinks it is, either. But the underlying story about how friends don't have to do everything together is a fine one, and there's also an element of how growing up can change how friendships work without destroying them. A fairly good song as well – not a classic, but moderately affecting. Finally, any episode with both Singin' in the Rain and Snoopy nods is going to make me pleased. For the fourth time running, I'm awarding three stars, and this time it wasn't an especially difficult decision. Maybe the first part of S6 wasn't quite as poor as I'd earlier remembered it to be.

Choice quote: Apple Bloom (in horror): "The Cutie Mark Crusaders don't have any reason to exist!"

New rating:

Next time, it'll be "Gauntlet of Fire", considered by many the first really good Spike episode. I hope I still like it as much as I did six years ago!

Sunday 28 August 2022

My PATW photo for 2022: Sunset and the Bull

After a slightly longer gap than I would have liked, I should be back to S6 rewatches tomorrow with "On Your Marks". (As in, I'll watch the episode today and do my write- up tonight, so it will be published tomorrow morning.) In the meantime, here's my single EQD Ponies Around the World 2022 submission. Sunset Shimmer with the huge mechanical bull (yes, he moves – a little) installed temporarily in Centenary Square, Birmingham to mark the city's hosting a few weeks ago of the Commonwealth Games.

For those who don't know the city, bulls are somewhat associated with Birmingham as a major shopping centre is called the Bullring. There is another, non-mechanical and smaller but permanent, bull statue outside that. The mascot of the Commonwealth Games was also a bull, but a rather cuter, cartoonier one named Perry. That name was inspired by Perry Barr, the region of Birmingham that hosts the city's main athletics stadium. The more you know etc etc.

But still. Pony. That's what we're here for, after all!

Wednesday 24 August 2022

Ponyfic Roundup 406

Read it Later story count: 90 (+1) 

The Thousand Words reviews were fun, especially given that I liked so many of the stories so much. I think I've read that Bicyclette plans on running the contest again in spring 2023. If that's accurate, I'll almost certainly be entering again, and probably reviewing again too! For this week, though, it's back to more normal reviews: four short stories that caught my eye for one reason or another..

Why Ponies Don't Play Golf by -The Storyteller-
A Pursuit Most Trivial by ReedHoarse
The Perfect Ensemble
by Papyrus Sands
Six Bronies by Alpha Scorpii

★: 0 | ★★: 2 | ★★★: 1 | ★★★★: 1 | ★★★★★: 0
Note: I use a skewed rating system. A fic I enjoy an average amount scores two stars.

Tuesday 23 August 2022

A chill wind starting to blow through UK fandom finances?

Anyone who hasn't been asleep for the past few months will have noticed that all is not well economically in the UK. I don't want to get into partisan political stuff here, so I'll simply note that energy bills are generally expected to go through the roof this winter, with inflation now heading strongly upwards as well. What does this mean? Well, for one thing, a lot of people are going to have a lot less money to spare on fun things than they'd like. If you're reading this, it's an easy guess what "fun things" might include for you.

Since I'm about My Little Pony on this blog, let's consider what that means for British Pony fans. First, it probably means buying less merch. Okay, the range of G5 official merch in our shops is really pretty poor anyway, borderline pathetic in the case of what's getting into supermarkets – but there is some around. And though it's not physical merch, there's also the question of Netflix. A standard subscription is now £10.99 a month. If you only use the service to watch MLP, that's absolutely not a nothing sum.

I expect there to be a knock-on effect on fan-made merch as well. I already know of people who used to be willing to spend say £50-100 on a piece of art from time to time who are now wondering whether they can really justify continuing doing that once their new gas bills hit the mat. The really expensive stuff like big plushies or ponysuits even more so.¹ Since we now have to pay chunky VAT and/or import duties from EU sellers, not the case in the first few years of the G4 fandom, I think these sales may be especially vulnerable.
¹ Okay, ponysuits are usually one-off purchases, but plushies a bit less so

Right, past the break I will get to the subject of conventions.

Saturday 20 August 2022

My Little Repeats 120: "The Gift of the Maud Pie"

Someone bring one of these to a convention!

S6E03: "The Gift of the Maud Pie"

2 Apr 2016

My original rating: ★★★
IMDb score: 7.7

The one with toyetic swan boats

Thoughts: For some reason the IMDb air dates for S6 seem to be completely wrong. The website says this one debuted in early June, which is rubbish. Oh well, to the episode itself... the Fox brothers' writing debut is a bit of a mixed bag. Though... I have to admit, this was considerably less dull than I'd remembered. Although I still feel Pinkie's craziness is overdone (certainly for this late in the series) in the first act especially, there's a surprising amount of really quite touching emotion here. Pinkie playing with the confetti to avoid hurting Maud's feelings is heart-wrenching, and though I'm not sure the businesspony really deserved the Wrath of Maud it is pretty amusing. Actually, Maud in general is used quite well comedically here. Rarity plays her "outsider" role reasonably efficiently, too. On the downside, this is another step in modern Manehattan taking over from olde-worlde Canterlot as the centre of Equestria, and I personally do not particularly like that. The first half of this episode is a two-star for me, due to Pinkie's iffy characterisation, but the second half is a clear three. As such, it's another ep I have to come down on one side of the line for. A bit to my surprise, I'm sticking with the higher rating. Maud, you're the main reason for that. More custom closing credits music is nice to hear, too.

Choice quote: Maud: "It's the only restaurant in the city with nepheline syenite in their bathroom tiles."

New rating:

Next time, it'll be "On Your Marks", a CMC episode that I had a reasonably good, though not amazing, time with back in 2016.

Wednesday 17 August 2022

Ponyfic Roundup 405: A Thousand Words Contest fics – Part Five: Gold Medallists

Read it Later story count: 89 (nc) 

Well, here we go. This is the PR when I look at the winners of each of the five categories, which to refresh your memory were Fluff, Angst, Humo(u)r, Grim and Experimental. I'm writing this intro before reading them, and I'm both excited and intrigued. I don't really know what to expect, since contest winners often stand out in surprising ways. That being so, I should probably stop rabbiting on and get on with the reviews! Here we go...

Wednesdays are Sacred by Aragon
Alicorn Ascentionism Tantamount to Plothole by Botched Lobotomy
As Above, So Below by Reviewfilly
The Sweet Sounds of Spring
by Rambling Writer
Womb by mushroompone

★: 0 | ★★: 0 | ★★★: 1 | ★★★★: 3 | ★★★★★: 1
Note: I use a skewed rating system. A fic I enjoy an average amount scores two stars.

Friday 12 August 2022

My Little Repeats 119: "The Crystalling, part 2"

There was so much fandom discussion about that mystery flying creature at bottom left

S6E02: "The Crystalling, part 2"

26 Mar 2016

My original rating: ★★★ (for the whole two-parter)
IMDb score: 7.3

The one with Sunburst foreshadowing some of the Pillars' names

Thoughts: My favourite part of this episode doesn't really include Flurry Heart at all. (Who is surprised?) It's the little scene in Sunburst's house where he and Starlight admit to each other that they're not quite who the other thinks, and that making friends is hard. It's nicely judged, and to my mind more interesting than the "toyetic, but let's not make toys" Hasbroism of Flurry herself. Some other good moments, such as Fluttershy gently patting the head of an annoyed Rainbow, and Celestia and Luna doing something for once. (Though I mentioned in 2016 that some of their stuff was dropped from the final episode, boo.) A lot of the episode feels rather predictable and by-the-numbers, though, and the crowd steadfastly refusing to move despite the blizzard goes on too long and becomes stupid instead of silly fun. Good to see crystally ponies again near the end, though not as beautifully animated as the S3 version – apparently that was too resource-heavy to keep on doing. Shame. Points for having both Twilight's parents get speaking roles (only just in Night Light's case) but I remain of the view that "The Crystalling" is the least interesting season opener to this point. As with part 1, this keeps its three but not by very much.

Choice quote: Spike: "Technically, she's more of a student than a protégée."

New rating:

Next time, it'll be "The Gift of the Maud Pie", which I had remembered as dull to the point of tedium but which most people (including me) actually rated quite well.

Thursday 11 August 2022

Andrea Libman to attend UK PonyCon!

Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy - Cheek hug by CaNoN-lb
( CC by-nc-sa 3.0 )

A few weeks ago, I reported the sad news that UK PonyCon guest of honour Kelly Sheridan had been forced to withdraw from attending this year's event. As I mentioned there, the UKPC people had said that they were exploring other possibilities, but I think deep down many of us didn't think it was very likely that they could get another show guest at only a couple of months' notice. Most of us were talking in terms of which community guests we'd be interested to see.

Shows how wrong we were! Yesterday, UK PonyCon caught everyone¹ by surprise – and how. Not only is it the case that UKPC will have a new show guest of honour, but that guest will be Andrea Libman. Yes, that's right: the voice of Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie will be attending the convention in person. It's fair to say that the announcement was incredibly well received, and quite rightly so. I think my first reaction on the little Discord server some of my friends group uses was something like "!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
¹ Okay, nearly everyone. It must have been so difficult for those who knew and had to keep quiet!

I am immensely impressed with this reveal. No Mane Six VA has ever attended a UK MLP convention, not even BUCK. And yet here we are with UK PonyCon breaking new ground, 12 years after Friendship is Magic debuted. Those on the con committee and elsewhere who helped make this happen, I take my hat off to you. And to Andrea Libman, thank you so very, very much for agreeing to come to UKPC. I hope Nottingham will make you really welcome this October.

Wednesday 10 August 2022

Ponyfic Roundup 404: A Thousand Words Contest fics – Part Four: Silver Medallists

Read it Later story count: 89 (+2) 

It's warm and sunny around here, and I'm just coming down off the high of a hugely successful Birmingham-based Commonwealth Games. (I only attended one event live, the road cycling time trial in Wolverhampton, but the atmosphere has been fantastic throughout.) That has nothing to do with ponyfic except to explain why I'm in a good mood even before reading five satisfying stories. As you can see from the star summary below, a very solid slate this time.

Stop Making This Hurt! by mushroompone
Laundromat by Admiral Biscuit
There is no Mare in the Shadows
by Equimort
Gull Sentry by daOtterGuy
Exciting Words and Phrases Regarding Four-Legged Equine Mammals, and Your Future Business Ventures Therein! by Silent Whisper

★: 0 | ★★: 0 | ★★★: 3 | ★★★★: 2 | ★★★★★: 0
Note: I use a skewed rating system. A fic I enjoy an average amount scores two stars.

Friday 5 August 2022

My Little Repeats 118: "The Crystalling, part 1"

Imagine if they'd done Pony Life in this style!

S6E01: "The Crystalling, part 1"

26 Mar 2016

My original rating: ★★★ (for the whole two-parter)
IMDb score: 7.1

The one with Starlight's deckchair

Thoughts: Surprise rewatch post! Here we are in mid-2016, by which time people were just starting to wonder not only how much longer FiM had to run, but how much longer it should run. "The Crystalling, part 1" isn't the most popular season premiere, partly because it features the never very fandom-popular Flurry Heart. I didn't find her a particularly appealing pony in my original review, and I still don't now – especially since I now know there would never be much done with her character. Mind you, they never did much with the Crystaller lore either. Maybe a good job considering how trivially easy it seems to be (for an alicorn, anyway) to smash the Crystal Empire's most vital artefact! Then there's Best Babysitter Sunburst. I liked him more as time went on, but he doesn't do all that much here. Oh well, at least it gives us the more interesting subplot of the newly reformed Starlight being anxious about meeting him again. Also, Sunburst asking Glimmy what she's been up to all this time amused me greatly. Frazzled Shining Armor is predictable and a bit dull at times, but he does the job. As befits a Crystal Empire ep, too, we see Spike get a pretty reasonable run-out.¹ At half-time, even with the slightly weird fairgroundy closing credits music, this opener seemed like it still had a bit of work to do if it wanted to be seen as a classic. Three stars still, but only just.
¹ Even if he does use "millennia" as a singular, grrr

Choice quote: Starlight: "This castle looked a lot smaller from the outside."

New rating:

Next time, it'll be "The Crystalling, part 2". I know, extraordinary ain't it?

Wednesday 3 August 2022

Ponyfic Roundup 403: A Thousand Words Contest fics – Part Three: Bronze Medallists (2/2)

Read it Later story count: 87 (-2) 

There were ten Bronze Medallists in the Thousand Words Contest, two in each of the five categories, so I split them into two for the purposes of Ponyfic Roundup. Today it's on to the second lot. I suspect one of my ratings this week will divide opinions, and perhaps rightly so, but I do at least try to explain why I've given it the number of stars I have.

Do You Remember? by The Sleepless Beholder
Of Rocks and Gems by Snow Quill
A Broken Crown by Dashie04
4:37 AM by Kris Overstreet
It Ur Flt Trixie (It's Your Fault Trixie) by Sparkling Twilight

★: 0 | ★★: 1 | ★★★: 3 | ★★★★: 1 | ★★★★★: 0
Note: I use a skewed rating system. A fic I enjoy an average amount scores two stars.