GPT-4 and Claude+ write ponyfic

It seems that if you log into Poe.com, you get one free query to each of the new GPT-4 and Claude+ engines in each calendar day. Given the vital importance of Pony, I chose to use today's free query to re-run the test I gave ChatGPT in December. I used exactly the same prompt as I did then, so you can compare the outputs of each model.

Prompt: Please write a My Little Pony story in which Fluttershy and Rarity discuss a sensitive issue over a cup of tea. The two ponies are very long-standing friends and trust each other completely. Both of them are quiet conversationalists, so the conversation should have a restrained emotional tone. However, the much brasher Rainbow Dash barges into the cottage halfway through.

1. A Delicate Conversation [by GPT-4]

Once upon a time in the magical land of Equestria, Fluttershy and Rarity were enjoying a leisurely afternoon together. The sun was shining brightly as they sat in Fluttershy's cozy cottage, the air filled with the sweet fragrance of blooming flowers.

Fluttershy had prepared a delightful tea party for the two of them, complete with an array of delectable treats. The elegant china tea set, a gift from Rarity, gleamed in the sunlight as the two friends sipped their tea.

Fluttershy took a deep breath and spoke up softly. "Rarity, I've been wanting to talk to you about something that's been troubling me."

Rarity looked at her dear friend with concern. "Of course, darling. You know you can always confide in me."

Fluttershy hesitated for a moment, gathering her thoughts. "Well, you see, I've been noticing that Angel has been acting rather... distant lately. I'm worried that I might not be giving him enough attention."

Rarity nodded, understanding Fluttershy's concern for her beloved pet. "It's only natural to worry about those we love, dear. But I'm sure you're doing your best to make Angel happy."

"But what if my best isn't enough?" Fluttershy whispered, her eyes filling with tears. "I feel like I'm failing him as a friend."

Rarity reached out and patted Fluttershy's hoof reassuringly. "Fluttershy, you are one of the most caring and devoted friends I know. I'm certain that you're giving Angel all the love and attention he needs."

Before Fluttershy could respond, the door to her cottage burst open, and in flew Rainbow Dash, her wings flapping excitedly. "Hey, you two! Guess who just broke the Equestria Speed Record? This pony!"

Fluttershy and Rarity exchanged a glance, their delicate conversation interrupted by their boisterous friend.

Rainbow Dash finally noticed the somber atmosphere and sheepishly rubbed the back of her neck. "Uh, sorry. Did I interrupt something important?"

Rarity cleared her throat, trying to maintain the relaxed atmosphere from before. "It's quite alright, Rainbow Dash. We were simply discussing a sensitive issue."

Rainbow Dash's expression turned serious. "Oh, I see. Well, if you need any help, you can count on me!"

Fluttershy smiled at Rainbow Dash's earnest offer. "Thank you, Rainbow Dash. That means a lot to me."

The three friends spent the rest of the afternoon enjoying each other's company, sharing stories and laughter. As the sun began to set, Fluttershy felt her heart swell with gratitude for her friends and their unwavering support.

With Rarity and Rainbow Dash by her side, she knew that she would find the strength to face any challenge, no matter how delicate the situation may be.

And so, as the day came to a close, Fluttershy, Rarity, and Rainbow Dash shared a warm embrace, knowing that their friendship would always carry them through the toughest of times.

2. [Untitled] [by Claude+]

Fluttershy poured Rarity a cup of chamomile tea and slid a plate of daffodil sandwiches towards her friend. "Thank you for coming to talk, Rarity," she said softly. "I know how busy you are this time of year."

"Nonsense, dear, I will always make time for you." Rarity took a delicate sip of tea. Though she and Fluttershy had been close friends for years, Rarity still found their heart-to-heart conversations somewhat taxing. But Fluttershy had been there for her in her times of need, and Rarity would do the same. "Now, what seems to be on your mind?"

Fluttershy fidgeted with her hooves. "It's about Discord. We've been spending more and more time together, and I think my feelings for him are growing deeper. But so many ponies still don't trust him, and I worry what they might say."

"I understand this is difficult for you," Rarity said calmly. "However, you cannot let the petty judgments of others dictate who you care for. As long as Discord treats you well and makes you happy, that is all that matters."

"You really think so?" Fluttershy asked.

"Of course, darling. Love is too precious to--”

Suddenly the door burst open in a flash of rainbows. "Hey Fluttershy, are you busy? I was hoping we could--oh, sorry, didn't know you had company!" Rainbow Dash glanced between the two ponies. "Did I, uh, interrupt something?"

"Not at all, Rainbow Dash," Rarity said, with the faintest hint of annoyance. "We were just discussing the complexities of interspecies romance. But do join us."

Rainbow Dash blinked. "Come again?"

Fluttershy blushed brightly. "It's a long story..."