Wednesday 3 July 2019

FiM special review: Rainbow Roadtrip

I'm aware that episode 14 was released early in China. I haven't seen it, so please don't say anything about it in the comments. Thank you!

"And the winner of Most Awesome Cyan Pegasus is..."
For only the second time in Friendship is Magic's history, we have a special outside the show's regular seasons. This latest one was a little different from last year's "Best Gift Ever", however. While that was simply a double-length episode animated in Flash, Rainbow Roadtrip was by all accounts a cut-down version of what Movie 2 might have been. It didn't have the series' opening credits, it was 60 minutes long – and it was animated in Toon Boom Harmony by Boulder Media rather than DHX.

If Rainbow Roadtrip had been announced this time last year, I suspect the reveal of Kim Beyer-Johnson as its writer might have caused some serious disquiet. At the time, she was known only for the widely panned "Non-Compete Clause". However, with Beyer-Johnson having at least partially redeemed herself with the considerably superior "Sweet and Smoky" a few weeks ago, I went into Rainbow Roadtrip with a reasonable amount of optimism. And as things turned out...

...it wasn't a bad way of passing an hour, really. I'll say straight out that the material seemed to be stretched a little thin for its run time, which does make me wonder what else was going to be included if this had ended up as a big-screen movie sequel. The pace of Rainbow Roadtrip was rarely hectic and was occasionally approaching glacial, to an extent that harked right back to some of the less action-packed early-series episodes.

"Us two should do... Barrel rolls. Hah! Geddit?"
The special might actually have worked better if it had been a 44-minute double episode. As it was, this felt all of a piece with some of the eps we've seen so far in S9: a modern interpretation of a basic idea that wouldn't have seemed out of place seven years ago. The script was reasonable, but in places seemed to show signs of repurposing from a film one: witness Rainbow's inexplicable use of "Princess Twilight" when the Mane Six were talking among themselves about why the townsponies were staring.

That animation, then. The rumours are, and have been for some time, that the G5 series will be animated in Toon Boom (albeit with a CGI prequel movie) and on this showing, I don't see any reason to fear that. Rainbow Roadtrip didn't look quite as attractive as the 2017 film, but then it didn't have a big-screen budget behind it. Given everything, I thought the visuals were really rather nice. The amount of greyness caused by the storyline did hamper the beauty a bit, admittedly.

If you've read much ponyfic, you'll probably have come across some variation on the "desaturated world" trope. (An interesting variation on the theme is Razgriz57's Pinkie Pie story The Only One In Color, which is gently recommended.) In this special, the Mane Six are invited to the Rainbow Festival in Hope Hollow, only to find that colour has drained out of its world – quite literally. They set themselves to trying to help restore brightness and happiness to the town.

Probably Fluttershy's second best scene
This is very much a Mane Six adventure as far as established show cast goes, with Spike left behind early on and characters like Trixie, Starlight and the CMC reduced to tiny cameos that recall their MLP: The Movie sidelining. While it's a bit of a shame to do that in this special, which unlike the big-screen film doesn't really need to simplify things for newcomers, it does at least avoid the temptation to give everyone they can think of a nod. (Hello first Equestria Girls film.)

Hope Hollow is apparently in Minnesota. I'm clearly missing something as a non-American, but FiM really seems to love that accent. Anyway, there are three major new characters: hotel owner (and much else) Petunia Petals, fashion designer Kerfuffle and grouchy handymare Torque Wrench. I thought they were all given solid characters, and it's unsurprising that Kerfuffle (with an intriguingly never-remarked-upon artificial leg) is the fan favourite. It's Torque for me, though.

It's at about this time in some reviews that I complain about the lack of things for Fluttershy to do. Rainbow Roadtrip wasn't a disaster in that respect, and 'Shy's scene with the apricots was one of her best and showed off her character development over recent seasons. She was otherwise mostly confined to making brief, cute observations, though, as well as simply helping Pinkie bake rather than getting a task of her own. I think "Sweet and Smoky" gave Flutters a rather meatier role.

At last the Colour Trout is over and done with!
The other pony who got a bit of a raw deal in 2017, Applejack, fared slightly better this time, not least because of her ability to talk to Torque. (Oh Logan, you are a card.) Even so, it was Rainbow Dash – perhaps unsurprisingly given the storyline – Rarity and Pinkie who again got the lion's share of the action. Twilight was on screen a lot, but for the most part she was simply going around talking to ponies and fanfillying over the library. At least she didn't get hit with another freak-out.

I'm undecided about how much I enjoyed the subplot with Rainbow Dash teaching the two foals, Barley Barrel and Pickle Barrel. They were fairly generic kid characters, and already I find myself struggling to remember much about them beyond the Rainbow Dash fan club. (Scootaloo may have something to say about that!) As far as Dash herself went, I did quite enjoy her aerobatic attempts to restore the colour, such as a sort of reverse sonic rainboom. I do think rainbooms have become too commonplace, though.

We had two and a half songs in Rainbow Roadtrip, the half being the 30-second introductory jingle. "The End of the Rainbow" gave an opportunity for Mayor Sunny Skies to provide some exposition as to what had gone wrong in Hope Hollow. I wasn't a huge fan: while pleasant, the tune was unmemorable and some of the lyrics rather awkward. The upbeat finale, "Living in Color", I liked considerably more – but it still didn't come close to the likes of "Open Up Your Eyes" or "Time to Be Awesome".

Perhaps Kerfuffle's leg's backstory was one of the things cut from the movie script?
The special's moral, that little acts of neighbourliness and kindness can help bring colour back to a grey and dreary existence, was a good one that fitted well with what Friendship is Magic is all about. It took a long time to get there, with some obvious stretching such as the Mane Six taking ages to notice the desaturation even after the hotel's (electric?) light was switched on. In the end, this goes into the "solid time-passer" category. It doesn't reach the heights the best FiM has, but it's fairly sure-hooved within the scope of its limited ambition.

Also: the American pronunciation of "apricot" really distracted me. I had no idea! (We say "ay-pri-cot" over here, for those wondering.)

Best line: Mayor Sunny Skies: "The trout doubles on harmonica."
Best moment:  Kerfuffle introducing herself to Rarity
Worst moment: "20 percent cooler" played straight. Please, no.

Yays
  • A very good, Pony-appropriate moral
  • One really excellent scene for Fluttershy
  • Some nicely varied guest characters
  • Attractive animation for the most part
Neighs
  • A shame the plot dictated so much greyness
  • Pedestrian pacing, sometimes very slow indeed
  • A few awkward moments in the script
  • Songs a notch below the show's best
★★★

12 comments:

  1. In which Friendship is Magic becomes its own one-off spinoff comic!

    I mentioned this somewhere else, but honestly, if you told me that G5 would centre on the Hope Hollow ponies and that this was our transition episode, I'd have been perfectly happy. Torque was my favourite of the new guys too, but Kerfuffle was adorable (and, as with Scootaloo's aunts, I felt just having a character with a prosthetic limb exist onscreen without drawing any kind of recognition or comment made me so very proud of this show), ditto Petunia with her background waving and cheery "Hellooooo!", the flustered mayor, the retired couple and their grumpy neighbour, the kids, the, um, Trout. I would actually watch My Little Pony: Hope Hollow Tales on a weekly basis.

    I feel I'm probably going to be in the minority, but I adored the "season 1 in molasses" pace of this. I fully acknowledge I'm biased in this regard - most of my own stories move at a similar pace, i.e. best enjoyed by those who find snails thrillingly fast, and as someone who generally loves the slice of life genre this was the absolute, um, sliciest - but I found it an absolute joy to just spend time with these characters, on holiday from their daily routines and from the main run of the series. I loved that there was no villain, no frantic plot time limit, just a whole load of largely empty space for characters familiar and new to stretch their legs/wings/whatever. We'll literally never have this chance in canon again to just watch the ponies ambling around like this, and I'm really and truly grateful we got to do it this time.

    Absolutely with you on the music. The abrupt clipping off of the first song was a surprise; Best Gift Ever got its hooks into me straight away with that soaring One More Day chorus, but this was as if it got truncated before hitting its stride. That second song was barely a "song" at all, either - barring a nice repeated hook line ('the end of the rainbow'), it actually reminded me a lot more of bardic poetry in that it was, essentially, a paragraph of fairly dense expositionary prose, sung so shapelessly that it might as well have been extemporaneous. I was exchanging disbelieving looks with my family through most of it - lines like "but the extra magic was too much for the rainbow generator" were... a thing that happened. And my son pointed out immediately that Living In Color, winner of Best Song by default, bore more than a passing similarity to Everything Is Awesome (from the Lego Movie). And he meant it as a compliment.

    Probably-not-entertaining trivia: Richard Curtis was so amused by the different ways Hugh Grant and Julia Roberts pronounced the word 'apricot' on the set of Notting Hill, he wrote it into a scene in the movie.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thinking about it, I think I would have been more than satisfied by 22 minutes of ponies just ambling around in a S1-type way, and probably still pleased with 44. For me, though, 60 was just that bit too long.

      And my son pointed out immediately that Living In Color, winner of Best Song by default, bore more than a passing similarity to Everything Is Awesome

      It does, too! I wouldn't have thought that was a deliberate inspiration on the lines of the old Sondheim-inspired songs, but you never know.

      Delete
  2. The Cloptimist3 July 2019 at 09:33

    Oh, also, et tu, China? Are there any countries left in the world now that HAVEN'T leaked or broadcast MLP/EQG stuff early? Off the top of my head we've had the UK, Canada, Australia, France, Norway, Denmark, South Africa, New Zealand, Italy, Mexico, the US itself, and now China too, all managing to mess up. I feel like maybe Hasbro should just leave the remaining episode master tapes lying around unattended at the UN, and see which country wants to go next.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rather surprisingly, Ireland doesn't seem to have had an early release. You can add Poland to your list, though: "The Fault in Our Cutie Marks" premiered there a few days before its US airing.

      Delete
    2. Well, given we only have about ten TV channels that aren't just UK channels broadcast here as well, that's no real surprise. But given we have all those UK channels, we've had them early too, courtesy of Tiny Pop.

      In part, over the show's run, episodes have been gradually delivered in final form to Hasbro earlier before release (perhaps the nearly year-long gap between Season 4 and 5 contributed a bit too). Sure, DHX recently fully wrapped production (as tweeted by Jim Miller), and judging by past years we won't get the last episode until October, a full four months after it was finished. So I can only guess that Discovery Family keeps to their schedule and Hasbro gives the episodes to all the overseas networks to air, and since they don't own those channels (whereas they do partly own Discovery Family), they have less leverage over making sure those territories don't air early. Or perhaps the policy overseas tends to be to dub and air them ASAP after they get them, to not fall behind the US airing, except they're not reliably informed the US airings are waiting in the can.
      Who knows, but I'll part all of the above is factored into these early airing trends the past few years.

      Delete
  3. I think you're right, 44 minutes would have let them cut some of the chaff (here's a scene of Fluttershy looking at butterflies! Now here's just the butterflies themselves!) and also tone down on the commercial breaks. D: Those things were ridiculous. And then it wouldn't have had to be an hour and a half! And I could have gotten my review out on time! And started helping my friend move sooner! >:| I'm still mad at this thing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Cloptimist3 July 2019 at 15:27

      The commercial break thing is probably an important point - I saw a download version that already had the many ads removed, which I guess may have made its horizontallyklaid back pacing easier to indulge when nothing much happened between breaks. Watching the Berrytube stream afterwards, it was definitely frustrating on that score.

      Delete
  4. > her ability to talk to Torque. (Oh Logan, you are a card.)

    This is completely random, but speaking as someone with a passing interest in differences of pronunciation, I feel like this may be lost on a lot of Americans, for whom those words wouldn't come close to rhyming...


    (Unless the joke is something else I don't get because I didn't watch it)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nope, you're right. It hadn't occurred to me, if I'm honest, but I'm not going to change it. Consider it a small, quiet act of push-back against the countless blogs (in this fandom and beyond) that make jokes only Americans will get. ;)

      Delete
  5. This special’s plot is decent but it should be shorter and more condensed. If the plot is too thin and too predictable, shortening the length time is a good thing, not dragging out. I feel like they try to appeal to the younger audience, so it explained why it feels laid back and simplistic. I have seen more complex mlp episodes in 22 minutes.
    At least this is another decent piece of works from the writer who wrote the worst ep so she redeemed herself.

    There are 13 episodes left, I hope the next stories will be more exciting because i'm hungry for exciting stuffs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it does happily seem as though "Non-Compete Clause" was an aberration. If we get another K B-J episode before S9 is up, I won't mind too much now.

      Delete
  6. Having rewatched it, it doesn't feel AS laggy without the somewhat overdone commercials (though the fades-to-blacks announce themselves much more so then a normal episode where they're properly baked in - some of these almost feel like they wouldn't be there in the actual version that'll appear on Netflix in the future), but it still should have been a 44-min episode. I can think of no clearer evidence of this then the fact that it spends 12 whole minutes - no, really - on the ponies meeting the Mayor, getting the tour of the highlights, the exposition song, resolving to help, and splitting. 12. Whole. Minutes. While cutting this down would obviously start with some visual pacing in places and trimming or removing/combining one of the "Mane 6 with a new character (s)" subplots, a sequence like that is an easy candidate to slash by a 1/3 of its length in a flash. That sequence especially felt like a first draft, in as far as any screenwriter will tell you their first draft always overshoots the required lengths (M.A. Larson once remarked his scripts almost always hit 33 pages rather then 30 at first; I've heard other writers nearly hit 40 on rare occasions).

    ReplyDelete