Present Perfect has reviewed Through the Well of Pirene. This is bad news, since I'd decided in my head that the story was so bloody long that I was only going to tackle it if it got 5/5. And you can guess what happened. So, at some point this year (I'm not being more specific than that!) it will become the second-longest ponyfic I've reviewed. One for the e-reader in the garden this summer, I think.
Anyway, on to the promised stats. Let's look at the star ratings I've awarded over the years, with the old out-of-ten scores converted in the usual way (grade boundaries at 4, 6, 8 and 9). Out of the 734 stories I've reviewed up to PR 143 (inclusive), this is the breakdown:
★★★★★: 34 (4.63%)
★★★★: 153 (20.84%)
★★★: 282 (38.42%)
★★: 199 (27.11%)
★: 66 (8.99%)
Some thoughts on this, plus more rambling, past the break.
It doesn't surprise me that three-star stories have been the most numerous. Unless I have a reason to do otherwise, I select fics to review that look as if I might like them, and a good, solid story that I enjoy and feel is a little above the usual run, without being a real stand-out, will get three stars.
The distribution skews towards the lower end, which again is unsurprising: a story that I find okay but not memorable, or one that has flashes of potential but also significant flaws, usually gets two stars. I've read more just-okay ponyfics than I have excellent-but-not-staggering ones (which get four stars).
My own hunch was that I've become tougher with my grading as time has gone on. To test this, I split the first 140 editions of PR into four equal periods of 35 each. These account for a total of 709 reviews. I reviewed significantly more fics in the third period, with the other three being almost equally split. Anyway, same format as above:
PRs 1-35 (167 reviews)
★★★★★: 16 (9.58%)
★★★★: 39 (23.35%)
★★★: 75 (44.91%)
★★: 28 (16.77%)
★: 9 (5.39%)
PRs 36-70 (168 reviews)
★★★★★: 6 (3.57%)
★★★★: 43 (25.60%)
★★★: 65 (38.69%)
★★: 44 (26.19%)
★: 10 (5.95%)
PRs 71-105 (204 reviews)
★★★★★: 9 (4.41%)
★★★★: 34 (16.67%)
★★★: 75 (36.76%)
★★: 61 (29.90%)
★: 25 (12.25%)
PRs 106-140 (170 reviews)
★★★★★: 3 (1.76%)
★★★★: 32 (18.82%)
★★★: 57 (33.53%)
★★: 58 (34.12%)
★: 20 (11.76%)
It's pretty clear that I have indeed become harsher with my marking over time: the proportion of one-star stories doubles after period two, while that of five-star stories drops significantly twice, after the first and third periods. A story like Stereo_Sub's RUN, which got four stars in PR 110, would probably have been a comfortable five in the early days. Two-star ratings have also (just) overtaken three-star ones.
One reason for this increasing toughness is obvious: now that I've read 700-plus stories, it's harder to blindside me with something special than it was when I was just starting out in the reviewing game. I also think I've become a little more confident in giving out low scores when I feel I need to, rather than tending to err on the side of generosity because, hey, ponies.
Finally, a quick "average star rating" index for each period. This is produced simply by multiplying each star rating by its associated percentage, then adding the five together. This gives the following:
Period 1: 3.15
Period 2: 2.95
Period 3: 2.71
Period 4: 2.65
A fairly even drop between periods 1-2 and periods 2-3, but a much smaller one between periods 3-4. This may mean that my criteria, subjective as they are, have stabilised. I'd like to think so, anyway. I wouldn't be at all surprised if "Period 5" (ie PRs 141-175) ends up producing the first rise, but there's a long way to go until I get there!
STATS ARE NEVER BORING >:V And either you've become harsher, or it's getting harder to find good fics.
ReplyDeleteAlso, wahahaha. :D
I don't think it's likely to be that it's harder to find good fics. You're still managing, and you've reviewed 4,000 of the things! Plus, there are plenty by reliable authors that I haven't so much as looked at yet. So though I can't prove it, I think it is much more likely to be increased toughness.
DeleteAnd indeed. Stats are great. I just couldn't think of an interesting title for this post. :P